Top Cheddar 2026-27

Tuesday, February 18, 1919 · Mutual Street Arena

Senators (1917) 4 at Arenas 3

Final/OT

Three Stars

By Game Score until the NHL names its three stars.

C 96OVR Frank Nighbor Senators (1917) First Star 1G · 2A · 0 SOG R 70OVR Punch Broadbent Senators (1917) Second Star 2G · 0 SOG RC C 63OVR Reg Noble Arenas Third Star 1G · 1A · 0 SOG

Scoring

1st Period

  1. 10:00 Reg Noble (10) Alf Skinner (5) SEN 0 – 1 TAN
  2. 13:00 Punch Broadbent (2) George Boucher (2) SEN 1 – 1 TAN

2nd Period

No scoring

3rd Period

  1. 7:00 Corb Denneny (7) Reg Noble (4) SEN 1 – 2 TAN
  2. 14:00 Ken Randall (9) Unassisted SEN 1 – 3 TAN
  3. 14:30 Frank Nighbor (18) Unassisted SEN 2 – 3 TAN
  4. 17:50 Sprague Cleghorn (5) Frank Nighbor (6) SEN 3 – 3 TAN

Overtime

  1. 2:30 Punch Broadbent (3) Frank Nighbor (7) SEN 4 – 3 TAN

Ottawa Senators (1917)

Player G A TOI GS
Frank Nighbor C 1 2 0:00 2.00
Punch Broadbent R 2 0 0:00 1.50
George Boucher D 0 1 0:00 0.40
Eddie Gerard L 0 0 0:00 0.00
Cy Denneny L 0 0 0:00 0.00
Skene Ronan D 0 0 0:00 0.00
Sprague Cleghorn D 0 0 3:00 0.00
Goalie DEC GA TOI GS
Clint Benedict W 3 62:30 -2.25

Toronto Arenas

Player G A TOI GS
Reg Noble C 1 1 0:00 1.38
Ken Randall R 1 0 0:00 0.75
Alf Skinner R 0 1 0:00 0.63
Corb Denneny C 1 0 0:00 0.53
Rusty Crawford L 0 0 0:00 0.00
Harry Mummery D 0 0 0:00 0.00
Goalie DEC GA TOI GS
Bert Lindsay L 4 62:30 -3.00