Top Cheddar 2026-27

Sunday, February 23, 1958 · Madison Square Garden III

Maple Leafs 2 at Rangers 4

Final

Three Stars

By Game Score until the NHL names its three stars.

R 96OVR Andy Bathgate Rangers First Star 2G · 1A · 0 SOG G 40OVR Ed Chadwick Maple Leafs Second Star 37 SV · .925 C 78OVR Dave Creighton Rangers Third Star 1G · 1A · 0 SOG

Scoring

1st Period

  1. 10:21 George Armstrong (11) Jim Morrison (18), Tim Horton (12) TOR 1 – 0 NYR
  2. 18:18 Gerry James (1) Jim Morrison (19), Gary Aldcorn (11) TOR 2 – 0 NYR

2nd Period

  1. 0:59 Red Sullivan (11) Unassisted TOR 2 – 1 NYR
  2. 16:12 Dave Creighton (10) Andy Bathgate (38) TOR 2 – 2 NYR

3rd Period

  1. 4:45 Andy Bathgate (23) Dave Creighton (29), Camille Henry (18) TOR 2 – 3 NYR
  2. 19:31 Andy Bathgate (24) Larry Popein (20) TOR 2 – 4 NYR

Toronto Maple Leafs

Player G A GS
Jim Morrison D 0 2 1.10
George Armstrong R 1 0 0.75
Gerry James R 1 0 0.75
Gary Aldcorn L 0 1 0.63
Tim Horton D 0 1 0.63
Paul Masnick C 0 0 0.00
Billy Harris C 0 0 0.00
Barry Cullen R 0 0 0.00
Bob Pulford L 0 0 0.00
Kenny Girard R 0 0 0.00
Frank Mahovlich L 0 0 0.00
Bob Baun D 0 0 0.00
Carl Brewer D 0 0 0.00
Ron Stewart R 0 0 -0.15
Marc Reaume D 0 0 -0.15
Goalie DEC SA SV GA SV% TOI GS
Ed Chadwick L 40 37 3 .925 59:29 1.45

New York Rangers

Player G A GS
Andy Bathgate R 2 1 2.13
Dave Creighton C 1 1 1.38
Red Sullivan C 1 0 0.75
Larry Popein C 0 1 0.63
Camille Henry C 0 1 0.63
Jean-Guy Gendron L 0 0 0.00
Andy Hebenton R 0 0 0.00
Parker MacDonald C 0 0 0.00
Hank Ciesla C 0 0 0.00
Gerry Foley R 0 0 0.00
Danny Lewicki L 0 0 0.00
Larry Cahan D 0 0 0.00
Bill Gadsby D 0 0 0.00
Jack Evans D 0 0 0.00
Lou Fontinato D 0 0 0.00
Harry Howell D 0 0 -0.15
Goalie DEC SA SV GA SV% TOI GS
Gump Worsley W 30 28 2 .933 60:00 1.30