Top Cheddar 2026-27

Sunday, December 21, 1958 · Madison Square Garden III

Maple Leafs 1 at Rangers 5

Final

Three Stars

By Game Score until the NHL names its three stars.

G 82OVR Gump Worsley Rangers First Star 25 SV · .962 L 51OVR Eddie Shack Rangers Second Star 2A · 0 SOG RC R 97OVR Andy Bathgate Rangers Third Star 2A · 0 SOG

Scoring

1st Period

  1. 8:20 Red Sullivan (7) PPG Camille Henry (14), Andy Bathgate (19) TOR 0 – 1 NYR
  2. 8:59 Hank Ciesla (4) Les Colwill (3), John Hanna (5) TOR 0 – 2 NYR

2nd Period

  1. 8:38 Barry Cullen (3) Bob Pulford (6), Brian Cullen (10) TOR 1 – 2 NYR
  2. 9:38 Bill Gadsby (2) Andy Bathgate (20), Eddie Shack (4) TOR 1 – 3 NYR
  3. 15:55 Larry Popein (6) Eddie Shack (5), Harry Howell (6) TOR 1 – 4 NYR
  4. 16:53 Andy Hebenton (13) Dean Prentice (14) TOR 1 – 5 NYR

3rd Period

No scoring

Toronto Maple Leafs

Player G A GS
Barry Cullen R 1 0 0.75
Brian Cullen C 0 1 0.63
Bob Pulford L 0 1 0.63
Willie Marshall C 0 0 0.00
George Armstrong R 0 0 0.00
Ron Stewart R 0 0 0.00
Billy Harris C 0 0 0.00
Bert Olmstead L 0 0 0.00
Marc Reaume D 0 0 0.00
Tim Horton D 0 0 0.00
Noel Price D 0 0 0.00
Allan Stanley D 0 0 0.00
Dick Duff L 0 0 -0.15
Bob Baun D 0 0 -0.15
Carl Brewer D 0 0 -0.30
Goalie DEC SA SV GA SV% TOI GS
Johnny Bower L 31 26 5 .839 60:00 -1.15

New York Rangers

Player G A GS
Eddie Shack L 0 2 1.25
Andy Bathgate R 0 2 1.25
Red Sullivan C 1 0 0.75
Andy Hebenton R 1 0 0.75
Hank Ciesla C 1 0 0.75
Larry Popein C 1 0 0.75
Bill Gadsby D 1 0 0.75
Les Colwill R 0 1 0.63
Dean Prentice L 0 1 0.63
Camille Henry C 0 1 0.63
John Hanna D 0 1 0.63
Harry Howell D 0 1 0.48
Earl Ingarfield C 0 0 0.00
Jimmy Bartlett L 0 0 0.00
Jack Bownass D 0 0 0.00
Lou Fontinato D 0 0 0.00
Goalie DEC SA SV GA SV% TOI GS
Gump Worsley W 26 25 1 .962 60:00 1.75