- First Star James Reimer 41 SV · .953
- Second Star Vincent Trocheck 1A · 2 SOG · 4 HIT
- Third Star Mike Hoffman 1G · 1A · 1 SOG
Scores
Thursday, February 14, 2019
- First Star Casey Cizikas 2G · 3 SOG
- Second Star Thomas Greiss 31 SV · 1.000
- Third Star Josh Bailey 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- First Star Andreas Athanasiou 2G · 3 SOG
- Second Star Jimmy Howard 40 SV · .952
- Third Star Matt Duchene 1G · 4 SOG
- First Star Nikita Kucherov 1G · 3A · 4 SOG
- Second Star Steven Stamkos 2G · 1A · 6 SOG
- Third Star Andrei Vasilevskiy 32 SV · 1.000
- First Star Brian Boyle 1G · 3 SOG
- Second Star Ryan Hartman 1G · 1 SOG
- Third Star Pekka Rinne 34 SV · .971
- First Star Gabriel Landeskog 1G · 4 SOG
- Second Star J.T. Compher 1G · 1 SOG
- Third Star Kyle Connor 4 SOG
- First Star Patrick Kane 1G · 2A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Cam Ward 41 SV · .953
- Third Star Jonathan Toews 1G · 2 SOG
- First Star Vladimir Tarasenko 2G · 3 SOG
- Second Star Jordan Binnington 21 SV · 1.000
- Third Star Joel Edmundson 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- First Star Auston Matthews 2G · 1A · 6 SOG
- Second Star Reilly Smith 1A · 3 SOG
- Third Star Cody Eakin 1A · 3 SOG
- First Star Brock Boeser 1G · 2 SOG
- Second Star Alec Martinez 1G · 1A · 3 SOG
- Third Star Kyle Clifford 2A · 3 SOG
- First Star T.J. Oshie 2G · 1A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Braden Holtby 25 SV · .962
- Third Star Alex Ovechkin 1G · 1A · 4 SOG