- First Star Jack Eichel 1G · 2A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Victor Olofsson 1G · 1A · 5 SOG
- Third Star Jason Pominville 1G · 2 SOG
Scores
Thursday, April 4, 2019
- First Star Steven Stamkos 1G · 1A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Andrei Vasilevskiy 29 SV · .967
- Third Star Mitch Marner 1G · 4 SOG
- First Star Brock Nelson 1G · 5 SOG
- Second Star Thomas Greiss 29 SV · .967
- Third Star Samuel Montembeault 35 SV · .972
- First Star Phil Kessel 2G · 1A · 5 SOG
- Second Star Sidney Crosby 1G · 2A · 5 SOG
- Third Star Matt Murray 33 SV · .971
- First Star Braden Holtby 33 SV · .971
- Second Star Carey Price 29 SV · .935
- Third Star Lars Eller 1G · 3 SOG
- First Star Petr Mrazek 36 SV · .973
- Second Star Nino Niederreiter 1G · 1 SOG
- Third Star Justin Faulk 1G · 4 SOG
- First Star Alexander Steen 2G · 1A · 4 SOG
- Second Star Jordan Binnington 26 SV · .897
- Third Star Alex Pietrangelo 3A · 0 SOG
- First Star Ryan Johansen 1G · 1 SOG
- Second Star Nick Bonino 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- Third Star Austin Watson 2A · 1 SOG
- First Star Jaroslav Halak 26 SV · 1.000
- Second Star Alex Stalock 32 SV · .941
- Third Star Charlie Coyle 2 SOG
- First Star Erik Johnson 1G · 4 SOG
- Second Star Tyson Barrie 1G · 3 SOG
- Third Star Carl Soderberg 1G · 6 SOG
- First Star Leon Draisaitl 2G · 7 SOG
- Second Star Brent Burns 1G · 1A · 1 SOG
- Third Star Joe Thornton 1A · 0 SOG
- First Star Derek Stepan 2G · 3 SOG
- Second Star Ryan Carpenter 4 SOG · 5 HIT
- Third Star Lawson Crouse 2A · 4 SOG · 5 HIT