- First Star Morgan Rielly 4A · 6 SOG
- Second Star Mitch Marner 1G · 2A · 3 SOG
- Third Star Frederik Andersen 27 SV · .931
Scores
Tuesday, October 15, 2019
- First Star Steven Stamkos 1G · 1A · 1 SOG
- Second Star Jeff Petry 1G · 6 SOG
- Third Star Andrei Vasilevskiy 33 SV · .971
- First Star Christian Dvorak 2G · 2 SOG
- Second Star Oliver Ekman-Larsson 2A · 1 SOG
- Third Star Mark Scheifele 1G · 1A · 5 SOG
- First Star Michael Frolik 1G · 2 SOG
- Second Star Brian Elliott 35 SV · .946
- Third Star David Rittich 21 SV · .955
- First Star J.T. Miller 2G · 4 SOG
- Second Star Brock Boeser 3A · 2 SOG
- Third Star Alexander Edler 1G · 2A · 3 SOG
- First Star Kyle Turris 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- Second Star Colton Sissons 1G · 2 SOG
- Third Star Cody Glass 1A · 5 SOG
- First Star Petr Mrazek 31 SV · 1.000
- Second Star Jack Campbell 21 SV · .955
- Third Star Martin Necas 1G · 1 SOG