- First Star Dylan Larkin 1G · 5 SOG
- Second Star James Reimer 23 SV · 1.000
- Third Star Andrew Copp 1G · 5 SOG
Scores
Monday, October 16, 2023
- First Star Sam Reinhart 2G · 5 SOG
- Second Star Sergei Bobrovsky 31 SV · .912
- Third Star Erik Haula 1G · 1A · 6 SOG
- First Star Igor Shesterkin 26 SV · .963
- Second Star Vincent Trocheck 1G · 3 SOG · 4 HIT
- Third Star Chris Kreider 1G · 3 SOG
- First Star Arvid Soderblom 35 SV · .972
- Second Star Andreas Athanasiou 2A · 3 SOG
- Third Star John Tavares 1G · 7 SOG
- First Star Matthew Phillips 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- Second Star Darcy Kuemper 38 SV · .950
- Third Star Adam Ruzicka 1G · 1A · 1 SOG