- First Star Adam Henrique 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- Second Star Alex DeBrincat 2G · 4 SOG
- Third Star Troy Terry 1G · 1A · 3 SOG
Scores
Monday, December 18, 2023
- First Star Sidney Crosby 1G · 1A · 4 SOG
- Second Star Valtteri Puustinen 2A · 3 SOG
- Third Star Vinni Lettieri 1G · 2 SOG
- First Star Cole Perfetti 1G · 2 SOG
- Second Star Gabriel Vilardi 1G · 5 SOG
- Third Star Josh Anderson 1G · 1A · 1 SOG
- First Star Matt Duchene 2G · 1A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Scott Wedgewood 35 SV · .921
- Third Star Joe Pavelski 2A · 3 SOG
- First Star Jacob Markstrom 33 SV · .971
- Second Star Mikael Backlund 1G · 3 SOG
- Third Star Sam Reinhart 1G · 2 SOG