- First Star Sidney Crosby 1G · 2A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Brad Marchand 2G · 4 SOG
- Third Star David Pastrnak 1G · 2A · 7 SOG
Scores
Thursday, January 4, 2024
- First Star Devon Levi 32 SV · .970
- Second Star Jeff Skinner 1G · 3A · 4 SOG
- Third Star Tage Thompson 2G · 1A · 4 SOG
- First Star Artemi Panarin 1G · 1A · 4 SOG
- Second Star Vincent Trocheck 3A · 2 SOG
- Third Star Jacob Trouba 1G · 2 SOG
- First Star Johnny Gaudreau 2 SOG
- Second Star Travis Konecny 2G · 7 SOG
- Third Star Damon Severson 1G · 2 SOG
- First Star Jonathan Drouin 2G · 4 SOG
- Second Star Tyler Seguin 2G · 5 SOG
- Third Star Nathan MacKinnon 2G · 1A · 7 SOG
- First Star Darren Raddysh 2G · 4 SOG
- Second Star Victor Hedman 1G · 1 SOG
- Third Star Marc-Andre Fleury 26 SV · .897
- First Star Blake Coleman 1G · 1A · 4 SOG
- Second Star Rasmus Andersson 1G · 1A · 3 SOG
- Third Star Filip Forsberg 1G · 2 SOG
- First Star Robert Thomas 1G · 1A · 2 SOG
- Second Star Jordan Binnington 25 SV · .962
- Third Star Colton Parayko 1G · 3 SOG
- First Star Bo Horvat 2G · 1A · 3 SOG
- Second Star Ilya Sorokin 26 SV · .963
- Third Star Mathew Barzal 2A · 2 SOG
- First Star Joey Daccord 32 SV · .970
- Second Star Andre Burakovsky 1G · 2 SOG
- Third Star Tomas Tatar 1G · 1 SOG
- First Star Matthew Tkachuk 1G · 2A · 4 SOG
- Second Star Carter Verhaeghe 1G · 1A · 4 SOG
- Third Star Sergei Bobrovsky 26 SV · .963
- First Star Lucas Raymond 0 SOG
- Second Star Robby Fabbri 2G · 3 SOG
- Third Star Daniel Sprong 2A · 4 SOG
- First Star Connor Hellebuyck 27 SV · .964
- Second Star Mackenzie Blackwood 28 SV · .933
- Third Star Gabriel Vilardi 1G · 2 SOG